Website Transition In Progress - Please Excuse the Construction
by Dr. Daniel J. Heller
We’ve written before about using weed—marijuana—to relieve PMS and PMDD symptoms. You can find the previous blog post here. It’s one of our most commented on posts, at least in part because—like much of our site, which provides the most comprehensive resource on PMDD and PMS on the web—it’s one of the few on the web on the subject of cannabis and PMS or PMDD. But many of the comments that have rolled in have told us something like “You don’t know what you’re talking about, pot works great for my premenstrual symptoms.”
So let us soften our previous message on this subject by pointing out:
To briefly restate what we said in the previous post on this subject:
Attitudes towards marijuana are changing rapidly, so we’re posting on the subject again. After all the responses we’ve received, we feel it’s important to clarify our position on this controversial subject. Just as attitudes towards marijuana are changing, laws are changing, and even the president of the United States said in a published interview that pot is not quite as bad as it’s been cracked up to be.
If you can use marijuana judiciously, without descending into abuse, overuse, or dependency, and it helps you, we’re happy that you’ve found an effective, natural, albeit temporary solution to your symptoms. We don’t have a judgement about it, and we are all for women taking charge of their own health. We continue to dispute, however, the mistaken notion that marijuana is the only alternative to prescription drugs, and that it treats the cause of the problem. We are biased, but feel our products, and our website, are a superior solution for women looking to balance their hormones and their moods, naturally.
by Dr. Daniel J. Heller
If you follow the news for PMS and PMDD information, you’ll occasionally hear about the latest new supplement or exotic herb being touted as a great breakthrough for women. We covered one of these before when we discussed saffron herb for PMS, which briefly got some attention from the media, and, not surprisingly, from some supplement companies as well.
There’s a new study that joins the ranks of the saffron study for several reasons. It was a small study comparing the herb fennel to exercise for the treatment of PMS, and of course some media outlets picked up on it. One headline from Europe even trumpeted, “Fennel could help millions of women beat the monthly misery of PMS.” While we like the herb fennel for a variety of reasons, this study doesn’t actually prove very much.
Like the saffron study, this one was done in Iran, where a surprising number of small studies have been done for PMS and herbs. And, kudos to the Iranian researchers who pursue these studies! However, usually these studies on herbs for PMS have similar problems: they’re quite small; they’re not placebo-controlled; and they are poorly designed.
Larger studies are always preferable to smaller studies. In a small study, it is easy to randomly arrive at a conclusion without realizing it is, in fact, random. When studies are done are large groups, it’s less likely that a random result will be confused with something significant.
When a study like the ones on saffron and fennel are not placebo-controlled, we can’t know if the women are helped simply by the belief that they are taking something that may help them. Our post about the powerful effects of placebo helps explain that even difficult conditions like depression can be helped by placebo, and that even supposedly scientific drugs like anti-depressants haven’t been proven superior to placebo. Often, scientific studies from non-westernized countries don’t use a placebo control group, which makes their results much less useful.
The design of a study is crucial to determining whether an herb, drug, technique, or other intervention is in fact useful. In the fennel study, fennel was compared to exercise, and a third group was simply observed (this third group is called “the control” group). Now, as we’ve pointed out before, no one has ever successfully proven that exercise improves PMS symptoms, even though we believe it does. But we know exercise does no harm, and is healthy no matter what. That is different than scientific certainty that it works. So an important flaw in this study is the comparison of one experimental treatment, fennel, with another unproven treatment, exercise, compared to nothing at all (the control group).
Another flaw is the way the researchers gave the fennel extract: three days before and three days after the women, in this case high school girls, got their period. The write up of the study was quite short, so the authors neither explained why they gave a PMS remedy for three days after the period, nor why they gave it for only three days before. Perhaps they didn’t understand PMS very well as we’ve pointed out so many times, many women get their PMS symptoms a week or two or even three weeks before their period. The administration of this potential remedy makes no sense.
Of course, treating only high school girls is a very limited population, so even if they had been successful, it wouldn’t have proven that fennel could work in any other age women. But given the small size of the study, this is only a small objection.
Finally, as is often the case in these studies, the authors conclude that the remedy worked. Given all the flaws in this study, if the herb did appear to work—and the authors concluded it was more effective than the exercise—all that is really reasonable to conclude is that it should be studied again, with an improved design, with proper administration, in a placebo-controlled study.
There are proven natural solutions to PMS and PMDD: Vitex herb, calcium, magnesium, and vitamin B6 all have been shown to be effective in well-designed, placebo-controlled studies. We also have plenty of common-sense suggestions that can help you get a handle on premenstrual suffering.